Saturday, November 28, 2009
Various casuality reports for Lee's Army at Gettysburg
Various casualty reports for Lee's Army at Gettysburg
Confederate reports for its losses at Gettysburg have always been questioned by historians. Many units underreported their losses or did not report as many losses as they obviously suffered. Determining the casualty lists for either side during the war is very difficult. But looking at Busey and Martin's book on the subject sheds some light on things. Growing up I always thought that Lee lost 28,000-30,000 men at Gettysburg but was that the case??
Lafayette Guild. Medicial Director of the Army of Northern Virginia reported 14,278 casualties in 1889.
Also in 1889 the War Department published 20,451 casualties at Gettysburg.
Details: 2592 killed, 12,709 wounded, 5,150 captured or missing
William F. Fox and his infamous study on the wars casualties reported Lee's losses at 20, 448
Details: 2592 killed, 12, 706 wounded 5,150 missing, he also noted a few thousand captured
The official reports of Lee's Corps commanders (Ewell, Longstreet, Hill and Stuart) reported 22,968 casualties.
Details: 2,701 killed, 12,739 wounded, 7,528 missing.
Historian Thomas L. Livermore calculated the Confederate casualties to be 28,063 which is the number that I most remember.
Details: 3,903 killed, 18,735 wounded and 7,528 missing, Livermore felt that the Confederate Corps commanders underreported their losses.
HIstorian Robert Krick estimated a loss of 22,915 men for Lee and his beloved army.
Details: 4,649 killed, 12,420 wounded and 5,830 missing
Busey and Martin whose book I am using for this post reported that Lee lost 23,231
Details: 4,708 killed, 12,693 wounded and 5,830 missing
Busey, John W. Regimental Strengths and Losses at Gettysburg. New York: Longstreet House, 2005.